Cocktails

New Old Fashioned

Choose Bulleit Rye, Woodford Reserve or Flor de Caña 12yr Rum with sugar, Angostura, Orange Bitters and a Flamed Orange Peel.

15
Bee’s Knees

Plymouth Gin | Lemon Juice | Honey Syrup

13
Mary Pickford

Bacardi Silver | Unsweetened Pineapple Juice | Grenadine

9
French 75

Jewell Gin | Lemon Juice | Roederer Brut

15
Hanky Panky

Junipero Gin | Sweet Vermouth | Fernet Branca

13
El Presidente

Bacardi Silver | Dry Vermouth | Orange Curaçao | Grenadine

12
Ward 8

Bulleit Rye | Lemon Juice | Lime Juice | Grenadine | Selzter

13
Side Car

Courvoisier VS | Cointreau | Lemon Juice

15
Our menus are subject to change based on the availability of products. If you have food allergies or dietary restrictions, please alert your server. An 18% gratuity may be added to parties of 8 or more and we can only issue one check for parties of 8 or more. Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of food-borne illness

Restaurant Reviews

Here's what guests are saying about our restaurant!

GREAT DINNERS AND BRUNCHES!

— Leona Aves, 5 August 2019

 4.2 Average Rating

Amazing place, fantastic atmosphere. Some things were spot on, others were good. Tomato salad was tasty, mushroom soup was delish. Monk fish really good but a little over salted. The old fashioned was disappointing definitely not the classic drink you’d expect from an historic bar. We’ll be back but will order simpler drinks.

— Gary, 30 October 2019

 4.0 Average Rating

The food served in your dining room is amazing: served HOT and your very polite and pleasant service people really know the menu. Everything was amazing except we feel the portion sizes are HUGE. We don’t see how anyone, with the exception of a linebacker, can eat everything on their plate. Also the majority of the menu has shellfish in some way, shape, or form. That limits the menu for those with seafood allergies (me). Even your daily soup was contaminated with seafood. I would understand all the “seafood” if you were located on the ocean. . . We would definitely recommend the Benbow to others and plan on revisiting your lovely inn again! We have been coming to the inn for 36 years. 🙂

— Tom Mcgoldrick, 8 October 2019

 5.0 Average Rating